Judge April Perry has spent months trying to get a straight answer about what happened in the grand jury room in the Broadview Six case. The Department of Justice has spent those same months getting more and more creative about making sure she never gets one.
This week, Perry ran out of patience.
Quick refresher. Six protesters, including former congressional candidate Kat Abughazaleh, were charged with felony conspiracy over a September 2025 protest outside the Broadview ICE facility in suburban Chicago. The case fell apart spectacularly in May, when prosecutors dropped all charges after Perry got a look at the grand jury transcripts. The transcripts showed that the first grand jury refused to indict, returning a “no bill.” So the prosecutor kept at it. She vouched for the case, talked substance with grand jurors outside the room, and excused the ones who disagreed with the government, until a later panel finally gave her the indictment. Perry said at the time, “I have never seen the types of prosecutorial behavior before a grand jury that I saw in those transcripts.” Then there’s the matter of what U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros knew and when, which didn’t exactly help his office’s credibility.
So Perry scheduled a hearing and asked Boutros and three line prosecutors to explain themselves. DOJ sent in Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward (who has been making quite the name for himself this administration) to make sure that never happens.
First, Woodward claimed that communications with the local prosecutors were privileged and off-limits to Perry’s inquiry. Then he argued Perry had overstepped by ordering Boutros and his prosecutors to testify, and demanded she “clarify” what the hearing was for, including whether it was about gathering evidence for a criminal contempt referral. According to Woodward, the court had presented Boutros and his subordinates “with a Catch-22”: they could “testify and risk prosecution, or they can assert their rights under the Fifth Amendment” and “risk antagonizing the court.”
And Woodward had a proposed fix. If Perry can’t get enough evidence for a referral without what DOJ considers an improper inquiry, then “the solution, however unsatisfying, is to simply not conduct the inquiry and leave the matter to the Executive Branch.”
LOLzzz.
Perry was not having it. On Tuesday, she called DOJ’s privilege log “noncompliant” because it left out the authors, recipients, and participants in the email chains. DOJ did hand over exactly one item she’d asked for: an October 14, 2025 email to Boutros with a grand jury transcript attached. But it came as a single PDF, “which does not provide any metadata about the email or attachment.” Perry explained that the whole “point of requesting the 10/14/2025 email and attachment was to provide corroboration,” i.e., to show whether and when Boutros actually read it. “The Government’s chosen manner of production thus sheds no light on the only relevant issue.”
On Wednesday, she took apart the rest of it. DOJ’s professed confusion about the hearing was “immaterial,” she wrote, because a court has inherent authority “to ask lawyers who have made misstatements to or misled the Court to explain their actions.” Then the real twist of the knife: “The Government does not represent at least 3/4 of the individuals who have been asked to testify,” two of whom “have expressed their willingness to do so,” and there “is no indication on the docket that the Government represents the fourth individual.”
Practitioners who’ve been around Chicago’s federal courthouse a long time are floored. Richard Kling, a longtime defense attorney who teaches at Chicago-Kent College of Law, told the Chicago Tribune he had never seen the U.S. attorney’s office or DOJ get called out like this:
“I have never seen it, I’ve never heard of anything like it from other lawyers. Quite frankly it is extraordinary to see.”
Christopher Parente, who represented former defendant Brian Straw, was blunter. DOJ’s filings, he said, show that “accountability and transparency are no longer on the table.” He also said, “The U.S. attorney’s office and DOJ appear to believe they are above the law,” and asked, “How can the U.S. attorney’s office hold others accountable for fraud and crimes of dishonesty when they refuse accountability for their own untruths and misconduct?”
The hearing is still on for Monday, whether DOJ likes it or not.
Earlier: Goodbye Broadview 6, Hello Broadview Sanctions
US Atty Boutros: If Not Trump Hack, Why Trump Hack Shaped?
DOJ Lawyer Can’t Avoid Bar Complaint By Declaring ‘Nevermind That Slush Fund Thing’

Kathryn Rubino is a Senior Editor at Above the Law, host of The Jabot podcast, and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. AtL tipsters are the best, so please connect with her. Feel free to email her with any tips, questions, or comments and follow her on Twitter @Kathryn1 or Bluesky @Kathryn1
The post Judge Is Done Playing Nice With DOJ Over The Broadview Six appeared first on Above the Law.

Judge April Perry has spent months trying to get a straight answer about what happened in the grand jury room in the Broadview Six case. The Department of Justice has spent those same months getting more and more creative about making sure she never gets one.
This week, Perry ran out of patience.
Quick refresher. Six protesters, including former congressional candidate Kat Abughazaleh, were charged with felony conspiracy over a September 2025 protest outside the Broadview ICE facility in suburban Chicago. The case fell apart spectacularly in May, when prosecutors dropped all charges after Perry got a look at the grand jury transcripts. The transcripts showed that the first grand jury refused to indict, returning a “no bill.” So the prosecutor kept at it. She vouched for the case, talked substance with grand jurors outside the room, and excused the ones who disagreed with the government, until a later panel finally gave her the indictment. Perry said at the time, “I have never seen the types of prosecutorial behavior before a grand jury that I saw in those transcripts.” Then there’s the matter of what U.S. Attorney Andrew Boutros knew and when, which didn’t exactly help his office’s credibility.
So Perry scheduled a hearing and asked Boutros and three line prosecutors to explain themselves. DOJ sent in Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward (who has been making quite the name for himself this administration) to make sure that never happens.
First, Woodward claimed that communications with the local prosecutors were privileged and off-limits to Perry’s inquiry. Then he argued Perry had overstepped by ordering Boutros and his prosecutors to testify, and demanded she “clarify” what the hearing was for, including whether it was about gathering evidence for a criminal contempt referral. According to Woodward, the court had presented Boutros and his subordinates “with a Catch-22”: they could “testify and risk prosecution, or they can assert their rights under the Fifth Amendment” and “risk antagonizing the court.”
And Woodward had a proposed fix. If Perry can’t get enough evidence for a referral without what DOJ considers an improper inquiry, then “the solution, however unsatisfying, is to simply not conduct the inquiry and leave the matter to the Executive Branch.”
LOLzzz.
Perry was not having it. On Tuesday, she called DOJ’s privilege log “noncompliant” because it left out the authors, recipients, and participants in the email chains. DOJ did hand over exactly one item she’d asked for: an October 14, 2025 email to Boutros with a grand jury transcript attached. But it came as a single PDF, “which does not provide any metadata about the email or attachment.” Perry explained that the whole “point of requesting the 10/14/2025 email and attachment was to provide corroboration,” i.e., to show whether and when Boutros actually read it. “The Government’s chosen manner of production thus sheds no light on the only relevant issue.”
On Wednesday, she took apart the rest of it. DOJ’s professed confusion about the hearing was “immaterial,” she wrote, because a court has inherent authority “to ask lawyers who have made misstatements to or misled the Court to explain their actions.” Then the real twist of the knife: “The Government does not represent at least 3/4 of the individuals who have been asked to testify,” two of whom “have expressed their willingness to do so,” and there “is no indication on the docket that the Government represents the fourth individual.”
Practitioners who’ve been around Chicago’s federal courthouse a long time are floored. Richard Kling, a longtime defense attorney who teaches at Chicago-Kent College of Law, told the Chicago Tribune he had never seen the U.S. attorney’s office or DOJ get called out like this:
“I have never seen it, I’ve never heard of anything like it from other lawyers. Quite frankly it is extraordinary to see.”
Christopher Parente, who represented former defendant Brian Straw, was blunter. DOJ’s filings, he said, show that “accountability and transparency are no longer on the table.” He also said, “The U.S. attorney’s office and DOJ appear to believe they are above the law,” and asked, “How can the U.S. attorney’s office hold others accountable for fraud and crimes of dishonesty when they refuse accountability for their own untruths and misconduct?”
The hearing is still on for Monday, whether DOJ likes it or not.
Earlier: Goodbye Broadview 6, Hello Broadview Sanctions
US Atty Boutros: If Not Trump Hack, Why Trump Hack Shaped?
DOJ Lawyer Can’t Avoid Bar Complaint By Declaring ‘Nevermind That Slush Fund Thing’
Kathryn Rubino is a Senior Editor at Above the Law, host of The Jabot podcast, and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. AtL tipsters are the best, so please connect with her. Feel free to email her with any tips, questions, or comments and follow her on Twitter @Kathryn1 or Bluesky @Kathryn1

