When the Trump DOJ openly adopted a bunker mentality, urging U.S. Attorneys to be “prepared for full-on battle” in the wake of the administration’s midterm shellacking, it was really just a matter of time before one of those thirsty MAGA careerists would concoct a publicity stunt to ingratiate themselves to the their DOJ bosses. That said, a Texas prosecutor threatening a Connecticut senator over something happening in Washington wasn’t on anyone’s bingo card.
So you’ve got to give Aaron Reitz, the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Texas, full credit for creativity!
Reitz kicked off his ill-advised assault on Wednesday, writing Senator Richard Blumenthal “to formally give you notice of your obligation to preserve all documents, communications, and other electronically stored information relevant to your intent to deprive citizens of their core constitutional rights to violation of 18 USC §§ 241 and 242.”
Blumenthal, the ranking member of the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, has written donors to Trump’s ballooning White House ballroom slush fund, asking how much they gave and whether they got anything in exchange for their “donations.” Reitz fired off his letter claiming Blumenthal “threatened citizens for associating themselves with the President and other public officials.”
Reitz promptly posted the letter on X, in case you were thought for even a second that this was remotely serious. But you’ve got to feel for Reitz… it must suck to snivel your way through the Federalist Society cursus honorum all the way to U.S. Attorney just to watch the administration hand federal judgeships in Texas to dudes from Ohio. A real slap in the face to the Texas MAGA locker room. It’s even worse for Reitz, whose political pedigree runs through Ken Paxton — whose bellyflop in the Senate race put the Republicans here in the first place — and Ted Cruz — who Trump has always viewed with the disdain he deserves. Broken clocks!
But the measure of a winner is not whether you get knocked down, it’s whether you get back up… and use your office to post frivolous legal threats for cheap headlines!
This is by far not the most important problem with Reitz’s tripe of a letter, but he spends the whole first paragraph whining about Blumenthal poking into people Trump “associates” with, reserving clarification about the ballroom issue for a footnote. I don’t know… it seems to me that the DOJ might not want to leave any ambiguity when they pull the “investigations into Trump associates” thread.

Because that’s certainly where my head went before I checked the footnote.
It is also extraordinary for an elected official to intimidate citizens for engaging in philanthropic practices that will benefit our nation for generations. The American people are entitled to freely associate without elected officials terrorizing them with aggressive, harassing government action.
Look, man, mafia kickbacks are just freedom of association in action!
Section 241 traces back to the Enforcement Act of 1870, which Congress passed so the federal government could go after the Klan terrorizing former slaves. NAACP v. Alabama, which Reitz cites, is about blocking segregationists from forcing a civil rights group to turn over its membership list. Contorting this to shield billionaires from an administration-run influence-peddling scheme takes chutzpah.
Reitz then demanded Blumenthal confirm receipt by 6 p.m. on the 18th.
Blumenthal, a former U.S. Attorney and state AG, replied with a refresher course in how law works:
The public deserves to know the terms under which dozens of American companies were persuaded to donate millions of dollars to the President’s vanity projects, and whether lawsuits were dismissed, contracts were awarded, or regulations went unenforced in exchange for that money. The public deserves transparency about whether the White House and the corporations it cajoled extracted favors at the expense of American taxpayers. Not only are these appropriate subjects for congressional oversight, but such inquiries are among the constitutional duties that Members of Congress must undertake to become informed about matters on which legislation may be necessary.
Of course investigating the prospect of executive branch bribery would amount to a legitimate legislative purpose. There are literally laws against it! Reitz decided to channel Trump’s nitwit WH Counsel Scharf on this point and faceplanted just as badly. Congress has wide latitude to determine legislative purpose, and subject already covered by statute falls squarely in that zone. How stupid is this kerfuffle? Gregg Nunziata, a conservative legal movement veteran, called it “pathetic and thuggish.”
But, while he was at it, Blumenthal made a request of his own:
Since you appear to have evidence of the Trump Administration’s efforts to protect corporate donors and Administration officials from legitimate oversight, I accordingly direct you to preserve all records and correspondence, including all communications with the White House or senior officials at the Department of Justice, related to the decision to draft and post your letter. Please confirm by no later than 6:00 p.m. on November 12, 2026, that you have received my letter and have taken steps to preserve the materials described above.

“[T]he decision to draft and post your letter,” zeroes in on the big question: is Reitz just a grandstanding dolt, or did Todd Blanche send him out here to harass a senator for clicks?
Also, high comedy collapsing that deadline to the 12th. Blumenthal even put it on Twitter just to make sure Reitz would see it. Reitz actually has quite the history with X, having mass deleted approximately 4,000 tweets right before his confirmation hearing for his job running the DOJ’s Office of Legal Policy. From CBS coverage at the time:
In another deleted post he appeared, possibly in jest, to embrace the anti-communist firebrand Joseph McCarthy. Above a picture of McCarthy, Reitz wrote, “Bring back the good ‘ol days.”
Oh, the irony.
“Received,” Reitz replied to Blumenthal’s post with a couple hours to spare before. But rather than leave it at that and preserve some dignity, Reitz attempted a double down:
Valid investigations must be conducted for a legitimate legislative purpose.
I believe that your threatenings may constitute the initiation of unconstitutional investigations conducted for reasons other than a legitimate legislative purpose.
We usually write “threats” instead of “threatenings” because, you know, the latter isn’t a word. I mean, it is a word, but only in the way that the English language is replete with archaic spellings. Since it’s not 1611, Reitz might want to stick with the language as it exists today.
Reitz closed with “Semper Fidelis,” a nod to the fact that both served in the Marines. Probably not as relevant as the fact that Blumenthal was as a U.S. Attorney before Reitz was born and then served as a state AG for 20 years.
But, again, why is the U.S. Attorney in charge of Houston doing this? Todd Blanche was asked that question and he responded with the level of intellectual clarity we’ve come to expect:
“Any office could investigate that,” Blanche explained lyingly. He then rambled about how he can’t supervise all the U.S. Attorneys in the system, despite that being his job. It’s the exact same move Blanche pulled when everyone started making fun of the Jim Comey sea shells case and he defiantly explained that he doesn’t know anything about what local U.S. Attorneys are up to even though Blanche announced those charges while standing next to the U.S. Attorney involved.
This is why “Disbar Them All” is a professional necessity. Texas Disciplinary Rule 3.09(a) directs prosecutors to “refrain from prosecuting or threatening to prosecute a charge that the prosecutor knows is not supported by probable cause.” Basically, prosecutors can’t treat their power as a career networking tool. Even if this letter conceivably supported a case, on its face it betrays that he’s on a fishing expedition. The reply “I believe that your threatenings may constitute…” does not make for probable cause.
There’s a reason why the Justice Department is suing the D.C. Bar and proposing new rules to keep state bars away from imposing ethical rules upon its lawyers. Licensing is the last accountability mechanism available. Trump will pardon everyone before this is over, but — as a profession — we can police ourselves and protect the public from anyone who uses their license to threaten legislators.
At least Reitz is now preserving documents for future disciplinary authorities. Not that he’s the sort of guy to perform a mass purge of his past documents to avoid scrutiny or anything…
Earlier: Disbar Them All: The Only Accountability Left For Trump’s Lawyers
White House Counsel Goes Full Mob Consigliere, Threatens Dems If They Investigate Trump
Joe Patrice is a senior editor at Above the Law and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. Feel free to email any tips, questions, or comments. Follow him on Twitter or Bluesky if you’re interested in law, politics, and a healthy dose of college sports news.
The post Richard Blumenthal Humiliates Grandstanding Texas U.S. Attorney With Remedial Constitutional Law Lesson appeared first on Above the Law.

When the Trump DOJ openly adopted a bunker mentality, urging U.S. Attorneys to be “prepared for full-on battle” in the wake of the administration’s midterm shellacking, it was really just a matter of time before one of those thirsty MAGA careerists would concoct a publicity stunt to ingratiate themselves to the their DOJ bosses. That said, a Texas prosecutor threatening a Connecticut senator over something happening in Washington wasn’t on anyone’s bingo card.
So you’ve got to give Aaron Reitz, the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Texas, full credit for creativity!
Reitz kicked off his ill-advised assault on Wednesday, writing Senator Richard Blumenthal “to formally give you notice of your obligation to preserve all documents, communications, and other electronically stored information relevant to your intent to deprive citizens of their core constitutional rights to violation of 18 USC §§ 241 and 242.”
Blumenthal, the ranking member of the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, has written donors to Trump’s ballooning White House ballroom slush fund, asking how much they gave and whether they got anything in exchange for their “donations.” Reitz fired off his letter claiming Blumenthal “threatened citizens for associating themselves with the President and other public officials.”
Reitz promptly posted the letter on X, in case you were thought for even a second that this was remotely serious. But you’ve got to feel for Reitz… it must suck to snivel your way through the Federalist Society cursus honorum all the way to U.S. Attorney just to watch the administration hand federal judgeships in Texas to dudes from Ohio. A real slap in the face to the Texas MAGA locker room. It’s even worse for Reitz, whose political pedigree runs through Ken Paxton — whose bellyflop in the Senate race put the Republicans here in the first place — and Ted Cruz — who Trump has always viewed with the disdain he deserves. Broken clocks!
But the measure of a winner is not whether you get knocked down, it’s whether you get back up… and use your office to post frivolous legal threats for cheap headlines!
This is by far not the most important problem with Reitz’s tripe of a letter, but he spends the whole first paragraph whining about Blumenthal poking into people Trump “associates” with, reserving clarification about the ballroom issue for a footnote. I don’t know… it seems to me that the DOJ might not want to leave any ambiguity when they pull the “investigations into Trump associates” thread.

Because that’s certainly where my head went before I checked the footnote.
It is also extraordinary for an elected official to intimidate citizens for engaging in philanthropic practices that will benefit our nation for generations. The American people are entitled to freely associate without elected officials terrorizing them with aggressive, harassing government action.
Look, man, mafia kickbacks are just freedom of association in action!
Section 241 traces back to the Enforcement Act of 1870, which Congress passed so the federal government could go after the Klan terrorizing former slaves. NAACP v. Alabama, which Reitz cites, is about blocking segregationists from forcing a civil rights group to turn over its membership list. Contorting this to shield billionaires from an administration-run influence-peddling scheme takes chutzpah.
Reitz then demanded Blumenthal confirm receipt by 6 p.m. on the 18th.
Blumenthal, a former U.S. Attorney and state AG, replied with a refresher course in how law works:
The public deserves to know the terms under which dozens of American companies were persuaded to donate millions of dollars to the President’s vanity projects, and whether lawsuits were dismissed, contracts were awarded, or regulations went unenforced in exchange for that money. The public deserves transparency about whether the White House and the corporations it cajoled extracted favors at the expense of American taxpayers. Not only are these appropriate subjects for congressional oversight, but such inquiries are among the constitutional duties that Members of Congress must undertake to become informed about matters on which legislation may be necessary.
Of course investigating the prospect of executive branch bribery would amount to a legitimate legislative purpose. There are literally laws against it! Reitz decided to channel Trump’s nitwit WH Counsel Scharf on this point and faceplanted just as badly. Congress has wide latitude to determine legislative purpose, and subject already covered by statute falls squarely in that zone. How stupid is this kerfuffle? Gregg Nunziata, a conservative legal movement veteran, called it “pathetic and thuggish.”
But, while he was at it, Blumenthal made a request of his own:
Since you appear to have evidence of the Trump Administration’s efforts to protect corporate donors and Administration officials from legitimate oversight, I accordingly direct you to preserve all records and correspondence, including all communications with the White House or senior officials at the Department of Justice, related to the decision to draft and post your letter. Please confirm by no later than 6:00 p.m. on November 12, 2026, that you have received my letter and have taken steps to preserve the materials described above.

“[T]he decision to draft and post your letter,” zeroes in on the big question: is Reitz just a grandstanding dolt, or did Todd Blanche send him out here to harass a senator for clicks?
Also, high comedy collapsing that deadline to the 12th. Blumenthal even put it on Twitter just to make sure Reitz would see it. Reitz actually has quite the history with X, having mass deleted approximately 4,000 tweets right before his confirmation hearing for his job running the DOJ’s Office of Legal Policy. From CBS coverage at the time:
In another deleted post he appeared, possibly in jest, to embrace the anti-communist firebrand Joseph McCarthy. Above a picture of McCarthy, Reitz wrote, “Bring back the good ‘ol days.”
Oh, the irony.
“Received,” Reitz replied to Blumenthal’s post with a couple hours to spare before. But rather than leave it at that and preserve some dignity, Reitz attempted a double down:
Valid investigations must be conducted for a legitimate legislative purpose.
I believe that your threatenings may constitute the initiation of unconstitutional investigations conducted for reasons other than a legitimate legislative purpose.
We usually write “threats” instead of “threatenings” because, you know, the latter isn’t a word. I mean, it is a word, but only in the way that the English language is replete with archaic spellings. Since it’s not 1611, Reitz might want to stick with the language as it exists today.
Reitz closed with “Semper Fidelis,” a nod to the fact that both served in the Marines. Probably not as relevant as the fact that Blumenthal was as a U.S. Attorney before Reitz was born and then served as a state AG for 20 years.
But, again, why is the U.S. Attorney in charge of Houston doing this? Todd Blanche was asked that question and he responded with the level of intellectual clarity we’ve come to expect:
“Any office could investigate that,” Blanche explained lyingly. He then rambled about how he can’t supervise all the U.S. Attorneys in the system, despite that being his job. It’s the exact same move Blanche pulled when everyone started making fun of the Jim Comey sea shells case and he defiantly explained that he doesn’t know anything about what local U.S. Attorneys are up to even though Blanche announced those charges while standing next to the U.S. Attorney involved.
This is why “Disbar Them All” is a professional necessity. Texas Disciplinary Rule 3.09(a) directs prosecutors to “refrain from prosecuting or threatening to prosecute a charge that the prosecutor knows is not supported by probable cause.” Basically, prosecutors can’t treat their power as a career networking tool. Even if this letter conceivably supported a case, on its face it betrays that he’s on a fishing expedition. The reply “I believe that your threatenings may constitute…” does not make for probable cause.
There’s a reason why the Justice Department is suing the D.C. Bar and proposing new rules to keep state bars away from imposing ethical rules upon its lawyers. Licensing is the last accountability mechanism available. Trump will pardon everyone before this is over, but — as a profession — we can police ourselves and protect the public from anyone who uses their license to threaten legislators.
At least Reitz is now preserving documents for future disciplinary authorities. Not that he’s the sort of guy to perform a mass purge of his past documents to avoid scrutiny or anything…
Earlier: Disbar Them All: The Only Accountability Left For Trump’s Lawyers
White House Counsel Goes Full Mob Consigliere, Threatens Dems If They Investigate Trump
Joe Patrice is a senior editor at Above the Law and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. Feel free to email any tips, questions, or comments. Follow him on Twitter or Bluesky if you’re interested in law, politics, and a healthy dose of college sports news.

