Every law school class has at least one absolute tool whose go-to answer for what they do for fun is something like “study the Constitution.” And while anyone who says that has dishonored their ancestors, they’re walking charisma compared to the clutch of federal judges that the Federalist Society gathered to talk about their hobbies.
Covering the FedSoc National Lawyers Convention, The Hill‘s Zach Schonfeld (as an aside, check out Schonfeld’s reporting on Alito whining to the conference) posted photos from the event’s “Lunch & SOC!” (cringe) session, where MAGA’s legal auxillary parked a bunch of federal judges at tables so they could bond with attendees over their outside interests, presumably while munching on Chick-fil-A. Something went awry with the signage because rather than neatly printed placards, some of these have strips of posterboard haphazardly cut and pasted onto the signs, like a ransom note.
But, friends, we’ve got to talk about how absolutely miserable it must be to dine with most of these people:

Ninth Circuit Judge Kenneth Lee listed his hobbies as “Professional Wrestling and America.” Unreal.
It should go without saying that “America” is not a hobby. The theme of the convention this year is the delightfully jingoistic “250 Years of American Exceptionalism,” so maybe Lee wanted to ace the interview by making sure everyone knew his biggest weakness is caring too much. Even if Judge Lee considers eating apple pie while blowing fireworks out of his ass a hobby, it’s not the sort of outside interest that drives conversation. “Oh, you have a performative relationship to the country too! How fascinating!”
As for the first half, you’re telling me that a FedSoc judge loves an enterprise where they put on an elaborate production to arrive at a pre-scripted outcome? No way.
Surveying the rest of the list, Seventh Circuit Judge Rebecca Taibleson put “True Crime Media,” because she basic. Though, in her defense, that’s at least an ice breaker. Maybe her true crime conversation can delve into the Epstein files, which she’s in. Yes, earlier this year, it came out after her uncle — who had retired from ASU after allegations of sexual misconduct — forwarded her legal advice to Jeffrey Epstein. There’s no evidence Taibleson ever communicated with Epstein herself, but it does make her a footnote on her own true crime podcast.
Holte and Sutton put running trials and “the law” respectively. You know the people who let their job become their whole personality? Fun people!
I swear these people were more interesting when they just used this conference to bitch about me, Elie, and Kathryn making fun of them.

Third Circuit Judge and Roy Cohn lookalike champ Emil Bove lists “Off-Grid Living,” which is a clever way to describe slumbering through the daylight hours in a crypt lined with your native soil. How did Bove get invited to the FedSoc party? Trump picked him after deciding Leonard Leo was a “sleazebag,” leaving us all somehow wistful for the era of FedSoc hacks.
Charles Eskridge makes mixtapes, so that’s the table to sit at if you’re trying to impress your crush and are stuck in 1995. Anna St. John is into historical preservation for all the HGTV stans out there. We’ll just pretend that in Louisiana that’s not 90% about plantations. Chad Readler seems to have called an audible at the last second and changed to college football. But he’s a Michigan grad so maybe he wasn’t sure he wanted to sit through 30 minutes of Connor Stallions jokes. We all need to know what he originally had there. But, congratulations your Honor, you have the only table worth sitting at.

“The Disparate Roles of District Judges and Circuit Judges”? Oh fuck you, Thomas Hardiman. That’s not a hobby, it’s a CLE literally nobody signs up for. Lee Rudofsky is into world travel, which he’ll have plenty of time to do while he’s NOT getting an Eighth Circuit seat. Can we take a second to applaud John Cronan for putting SCUBA diving? For a bunch of textualists, it’s nice to see at least one of them can read.
James Ho’s sign just says “You’ve Got to Have Hobbies.” Holy shit. True renaissance man right here. Just put “desperately auditioning for a job” and at least be honest.
Talking to these people is like watching paint dry if the paint also wanted to take away civil rights.

Matthew Kacsmaryk chose snowboarding. Is there a lot of snowboarding in Amarillo? Actually, wait, it doesn’t matter because he legitimately believes he has power everywhere. Flowers pulled a Hardiman and put “Building a Career Between the Courts.” I wonder if they lied to him and told him he had a real panel session and then dropped “Surprise! You’re just anchoring Suckup Supper.” Edith Jones likes choir music, which is fine, but then added “random ways to relax.” At this point, you have to blame the organizers for not saving these absolute dullards from themselves as the answers rolled in. Maybe going full loony on law professors counts as a “random way to relax.”
True doorknob Lawrence VanDyke went with “Balancing Work with Faith, Family, and Fun.” That’s called “being a person.” Dude, just say “guns.” He put out an 18-minute video dissent of himself fondling his guns — at least hunting is a hobby.
Conference organizers probably thought they had a cute idea setting up a lunch to convince law students that the conservative legal movement is made up of well-rounded people with rich inner lives. Instead they got this. It’s like the Grinch except they’re born with personalities two sizes two small.
Except there’s no redemption arc. Just misery all the way down.
Earlier: Federal Judge Weeps For Poor Defenseless Federalist Society, Ruthlessly Bullied By Legal Bloggers
A Federal Judge’s Name Surfaces In The Epstein Files
Judge Emil Bove Set Trump Assassination Photo As His Phone’s Lock Screen, Like A Proper Henchman
James Ho Uses Opinion To Whine About People Accusing Judges Of Auditioning For Promotions
Joe Patrice is a senior editor at Above the Law and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. Feel free to email any tips, questions, or comments. Follow him on Twitter or Bluesky if you’re interested in law, politics, and a healthy dose of college sports news.
The post Federalist Society Judges List Their Hobbies And They’re Total Dorks appeared first on Above the Law.

Every law school class has at least one absolute tool whose go-to answer for what they do for fun is something like “study the Constitution.” And while anyone who says that has dishonored their ancestors, they’re walking charisma compared to the clutch of federal judges that the Federalist Society gathered to talk about their hobbies.
Covering the FedSoc National Lawyers Convention, The Hill‘s Zach Schonfeld (as an aside, check out Schonfeld’s reporting on Alito whining to the conference) posted photos from the event’s “Lunch & SOC!” (cringe) session, where MAGA’s legal auxillary parked a bunch of federal judges at tables so they could bond with attendees over their outside interests, presumably while munching on Chick-fil-A. Something went awry with the signage because rather than neatly printed placards, some of these have strips of posterboard haphazardly cut and pasted onto the signs, like a ransom note.
But, friends, we’ve got to talk about how absolutely miserable it must be to dine with most of these people:

Ninth Circuit Judge Kenneth Lee listed his hobbies as “Professional Wrestling and America.” Unreal.
It should go without saying that “America” is not a hobby. The theme of the convention this year is the delightfully jingoistic “250 Years of American Exceptionalism,” so maybe Lee wanted to ace the interview by making sure everyone knew his biggest weakness is caring too much. Even if Judge Lee considers eating apple pie while blowing fireworks out of his ass a hobby, it’s not the sort of outside interest that drives conversation. “Oh, you have a performative relationship to the country too! How fascinating!”
As for the first half, you’re telling me that a FedSoc judge loves an enterprise where they put on an elaborate production to arrive at a pre-scripted outcome? No way.
Surveying the rest of the list, Seventh Circuit Judge Rebecca Taibleson put “True Crime Media,” because she basic. Though, in her defense, that’s at least an ice breaker. Maybe her true crime conversation can delve into the Epstein files, which she’s in. Yes, earlier this year, it came out after her uncle — who had retired from ASU after allegations of sexual misconduct — forwarded her legal advice to Jeffrey Epstein. There’s no evidence Taibleson ever communicated with Epstein herself, but it does make her a footnote on her own true crime podcast.
Holte and Sutton put running trials and “the law” respectively. You know the people who let their job become their whole personality? Fun people!
I swear these people were more interesting when they just used this conference to bitch about me, Elie, and Kathryn making fun of them.

Third Circuit Judge and Roy Cohn lookalike champ Emil Bove lists “Off-Grid Living,” which is a clever way to describe slumbering through the daylight hours in a crypt lined with your native soil. How did Bove get invited to the FedSoc party? Trump picked him after deciding Leonard Leo was a “sleazebag,” leaving us all somehow wistful for the era of FedSoc hacks.
Charles Eskridge makes mixtapes, so that’s the table to sit at if you’re trying to impress your crush and are stuck in 1995. Anna St. John is into historical preservation for all the HGTV stans out there. We’ll just pretend that in Louisiana that’s not 90% about plantations. Chad Readler seems to have called an audible at the last second and changed to college football. But he’s a Michigan grad so maybe he wasn’t sure he wanted to sit through 30 minutes of Connor Stallions jokes. We all need to know what he originally had there. But, congratulations your Honor, you have the only table worth sitting at.

“The Disparate Roles of District Judges and Circuit Judges”? Oh fuck you, Thomas Hardiman. That’s not a hobby, it’s a CLE literally nobody signs up for. Lee Rudofsky is into world travel, which he’ll have plenty of time to do while he’s NOT getting an Eighth Circuit seat. Can we take a second to applaud John Cronan for putting SCUBA diving? For a bunch of textualists, it’s nice to see at least one of them can read.
James Ho’s sign just says “You’ve Got to Have Hobbies.” Holy shit. True renaissance man right here. Just put “desperately auditioning for a job” and at least be honest.
Talking to these people is like watching paint dry if the paint also wanted to take away civil rights.

Matthew Kacsmaryk chose snowboarding. Is there a lot of snowboarding in Amarillo? Actually, wait, it doesn’t matter because he legitimately believes he has power everywhere. Flowers pulled a Hardiman and put “Building a Career Between the Courts.” I wonder if they lied to him and told him he had a real panel session and then dropped “Surprise! You’re just anchoring Suckup Supper.” Edith Jones likes choir music, which is fine, but then added “random ways to relax.” At this point, you have to blame the organizers for not saving these absolute dullards from themselves as the answers rolled in. Maybe going full loony on law professors counts as a “random way to relax.”
True doorknob Lawrence VanDyke went with “Balancing Work with Faith, Family, and Fun.” That’s called “being a person.” Dude, just say “guns.” He put out an 18-minute video dissent of himself fondling his guns — at least hunting is a hobby.
Conference organizers probably thought they had a cute idea setting up a lunch to convince law students that the conservative legal movement is made up of well-rounded people with rich inner lives. Instead they got this. It’s like the Grinch except they’re born with personalities two sizes two small.
Except there’s no redemption arc. Just misery all the way down.
Earlier: Federal Judge Weeps For Poor Defenseless Federalist Society, Ruthlessly Bullied By Legal Bloggers
A Federal Judge’s Name Surfaces In The Epstein Files
Judge Emil Bove Set Trump Assassination Photo As His Phone’s Lock Screen, Like A Proper Henchman
James Ho Uses Opinion To Whine About People Accusing Judges Of Auditioning For Promotions
Joe Patrice is a senior editor at Above the Law and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. Feel free to email any tips, questions, or comments. Follow him on Twitter or Bluesky if you’re interested in law, politics, and a healthy dose of college sports news.

