Listen, law school recruiting is a mess, and everyone knows it. When NALP scrapped its decades-old recruiting guidelines back in 2018, the race to the bottom was on. Seven years later, Biglaw’s recruitment of law students is well and truly broken, and it’s worse for the students, the firms, and the law schools alike. 1Ls are securing their 2L summer jobs before their 1L summer jobs. Some firms are now skipping screening interviews entirely and sending 1Ls straight to callbacks before they’ve sat for a single law school exam. The competition for top-tier legal talent coming out of law school has gotten insane.
So when an elite firm announces it’s pushing back on the early-hiring frenzy, you’d expect to be cheering. But, oof, this is a choice.
San Francisco’s Keker, Van Nest & Peters will stop giving full-time offers to summer associates at the end of the summer, Reuters reports, and will instead have them apply for those jobs “when they are ready.” The change takes effect in 2028. Here’s how partner and hiring committee chair Sharif Jacob explained it:
“We believe it would be better for the associates and the firm if they just have a little bit more experience before they have to make these big decisions. So we’re encouraging that.”
This is absolutely not the way to push back on what’s wrong with law school recruitment.
Even before on-campus recruiting became a shadow of its former self, getting an offer after your 2L summer was the standard. That was the whole point of the summer program. If for some reason you didn’t get one, it was strange, because almost everyone did. Remember back in 2003 when a Skadden summer associate meant to tell one friend he was “busy doing jack shit” after a two-hour sushi lunch, and instead sent it to the firm’s entire underwriting group, partners included, still got the full-time offer.
So what exactly is Keker trying to do here? Make it so no one actually wants to do its summer program? Keker’s is relatively small, 10 or so summers, and it’s competing for the same elite-credentialed students as everyone else. Why would someone with those credentials spend a summer on a program that won’t get them a post-graduation job when 99.9% of their other options will? Why drag the stress of the job hunt into 3L year (imho, the most fun of all the law school years) when you don’t have to? And the backup plan for anyone opting into this revamped program isn’t great. 3Ls have fewer chances than ever to interview for full-time jobs, because firms filled their classes with the summers they locked down as 1Ls.
Maybe Keker is signaling that it really only wants associates with clerkship experience. “A little bit more experience before they have to make these big decisions” sounds a lot like “go clerk, then call us.” That’s a defensible hiring philosophy for a trial shop — but then say that! Don’t make it so that your summer program is the least attractive offer on the table.
The problem with law school recruiting is on the front end: first-semester 1Ls choosing their careers before they’ve gotten a single grade. A couple of firms, like Cooley and Susman Godfrey, have already pulled back from that 1L hiring model, and that change actually goes after the problem. But once they’re actually summer associates, taking a full-time offer off the table only punishes those who chose the firm.
Something has to be done about law school recruitment, but this ain’t it.
Earlier: Biglaw Skipping 1L Interviews And Going Straight To Callbacks Before First-Semester Exams
When Biglaw Ruins Everything, Law Schools Have To Adapt
Exclusive: Biglaw Firms Farming Out Law School Recruitment Efforts To Current Law Students
The Biglaw Recruitment Process Is Worse For Everyone

Kathryn Rubino is a Senior Editor at Above the Law, host of The Jabot podcast, and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. AtL tipsters are the best, so please connect with her. Feel free to email her with any tips, questions, or comments and follow her on Twitter @Kathryn1 or Bluesky @Kathryn1
The post Litigation Boutique Makes Its Summer Program The Worst Deal In Town appeared first on Above the Law.

Listen, law school recruiting is a mess, and everyone knows it. When NALP scrapped its decades-old recruiting guidelines back in 2018, the race to the bottom was on. Seven years later, Biglaw’s recruitment of law students is well and truly broken, and it’s worse for the students, the firms, and the law schools alike. 1Ls are securing their 2L summer jobs before their 1L summer jobs. Some firms are now skipping screening interviews entirely and sending 1Ls straight to callbacks before they’ve sat for a single law school exam. The competition for top-tier legal talent coming out of law school has gotten insane.
So when an elite firm announces it’s pushing back on the early-hiring frenzy, you’d expect to be cheering. But, oof, this is a choice.
San Francisco’s Keker, Van Nest & Peters will stop giving full-time offers to summer associates at the end of the summer, Reuters reports, and will instead have them apply for those jobs “when they are ready.” The change takes effect in 2028. Here’s how partner and hiring committee chair Sharif Jacob explained it:
“We believe it would be better for the associates and the firm if they just have a little bit more experience before they have to make these big decisions. So we’re encouraging that.”
This is absolutely not the way to push back on what’s wrong with law school recruitment.
Even before on-campus recruiting became a shadow of its former self, getting an offer after your 2L summer was the standard. That was the whole point of the summer program. If for some reason you didn’t get one, it was strange, because almost everyone did. Remember back in 2003 when a Skadden summer associate meant to tell one friend he was “busy doing jack shit” after a two-hour sushi lunch, and instead sent it to the firm’s entire underwriting group, partners included, still got the full-time offer.
So what exactly is Keker trying to do here? Make it so no one actually wants to do its summer program? Keker’s is relatively small, 10 or so summers, and it’s competing for the same elite-credentialed students as everyone else. Why would someone with those credentials spend a summer on a program that won’t get them a post-graduation job when 99.9% of their other options will? Why drag the stress of the job hunt into 3L year (imho, the most fun of all the law school years) when you don’t have to? And the backup plan for anyone opting into this revamped program isn’t great. 3Ls have fewer chances than ever to interview for full-time jobs, because firms filled their classes with the summers they locked down as 1Ls.
Maybe Keker is signaling that it really only wants associates with clerkship experience. “A little bit more experience before they have to make these big decisions” sounds a lot like “go clerk, then call us.” That’s a defensible hiring philosophy for a trial shop — but then say that! Don’t make it so that your summer program is the least attractive offer on the table.
The problem with law school recruiting is on the front end: first-semester 1Ls choosing their careers before they’ve gotten a single grade. A couple of firms, like Cooley and Susman Godfrey, have already pulled back from that 1L hiring model, and that change actually goes after the problem. But once they’re actually summer associates, taking a full-time offer off the table only punishes those who chose the firm.
Something has to be done about law school recruitment, but this ain’t it.
Earlier: Biglaw Skipping 1L Interviews And Going Straight To Callbacks Before First-Semester Exams
When Biglaw Ruins Everything, Law Schools Have To Adapt
Exclusive: Biglaw Firms Farming Out Law School Recruitment Efforts To Current Law Students
The Biglaw Recruitment Process Is Worse For Everyone
Kathryn Rubino is a Senior Editor at Above the Law, host of The Jabot podcast, and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. AtL tipsters are the best, so please connect with her. Feel free to email her with any tips, questions, or comments and follow her on Twitter @Kathryn1 or Bluesky @Kathryn1

