Bob Giuffra 524x735
Bob Giuffra

Sullivan & Cromwell is getting new leadership. On Thursday, the 147-year-old white-shoe firm announced that co-chairs Robert “Bob” Giuffra Jr. and Scott Miller will step down at the end of 2027, with Frankfurt managing partner Carsten Berrar and litigation managing partner Sharon Nelles taking over on January 1, 2028, according to Bloomberg Law. Nelles will be the first woman to lead the firm in its history.

When Giuffra and Miller took over, S&C went in a new direction, establishing co-chairs for the first time. But that wasn’t really the headline for the Giuffra/Miller era at the firm.

With all due respect to Miller, the half of the partnership who did not spend the last two years as Donald Trump’s personal lawyer, the story here is Giuffra. He has been the face of S&C’s Trump era since the start. Back in Trump’s first term, S&C was reportedly one of the firms that told him no. Then in January 2025, Giuffra personally took the lead on Trump’s appeal of the hush money conviction, to a less-than-thrilled reception inside the firm. A few months later, it came out that he’d been in the room alongside Boris Epshteyn when Paul Weiss negotiated the first of the Biglaw capitulation deals. That raised the not-small question of where Giuffra’s work as Trump’s personal lawyer ended and his advice on how Trump uses presidential power began, and the firm’s ethics ended up in the spotlight. Then he showed up at the Second Circuit for an E. Jean Carroll argument that wasn’t his case, standing next to Epshteyn. George Conway, whose best man was Giuffra at his wedding to former Trump adviser Kellyanne Conway, called the whole thing a “disgrace.” The man knows a lot about losing people close to him to MAGA.

And then came the red line. Giuffra reportedly assured partners that the firm would stay out of the Carroll litigation. This summer, his name was on the Supreme Court petition anyway.

Meanwhile, the firm turned into a pipeline to the administration: Jay Clayton, then Jamie McDonald at SDNY, then Matthew Schwartz nominated to the Second Circuit as the cozy relationship got even cozier. The money is real too. Trump’s Save America PAC, which went into debt to its lawyers earlier this year, paid S&C $3.8 million through September, according to FEC filings.

So how does the firm describe the handoff? “Careful and deliberate succession planning and a commitment to stewardship have been central to S&C’s success since our founding in 1879,” Giuffra and Miller said in a statement.

One thing the announcement doesn’t do is end anything anytime soon. Giuffra stays co-chair for another 13 months. Even after that, he isn’t going anywhere: like past S&C leaders, he and Miller will become senior chairs and keep their practices. S&C still represents Trump in the hush money appeal and in the civil fraud case brought by New York Attorney General Letitia James. Nothing here suggests either matter is moving.

Which brings us to Berrar and Nelles, their résumés are classic S&C. Berrar co-heads the firm’s global capital markets group and led the team advising Delivery Hero on its €13 billion combination with Uber. Nelles steered Volkswagen through its diesel emissions settlements and represented JPMorgan and Moody’s after the financial crisis. That’s the kind of work S&C was known for before Giuffra made Donald Trump its most famous client.

But a succession plan isn’t a course correction. Giuffra isn’t being pushed out; he’s just the next S&C leader to follow the firm’s long-standing succession plan, with a senior chair title waiting for him at the end. A new name at the top doesn’t automatically mean a new reputation, and whether S&C can break free of its MAGA run remains to be seen.


IMG 5243 1 scaled e1623338814705Kathryn Rubino is a Senior Editor at Above the Law, host of The Jabot podcast, and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. AtL tipsters are the best, so please connect with her. Feel free to email her with any tips, questions, or comments and follow her on Twitter @Kathryn1 or Bluesky @Kathryn1