Law firms started throwing the hiring cycle into disarray a few years ago, blowing off the tried and true on-campus interviewing regime to start recruiting in the middle of the academic year. As students and law schools complained about the incursion, the firms upped the ante, beginning to interview future lawyers before students even take first-semester exams.
Now we’re hearing that at least a couple firms have gone further, eschewing initial interviews altogether and jumping straight to callbacks based on nothing but an application and vibes. Meanwhile, students have to show up to class in suits so they can bolt the moment the lecture ends. Which isn’t necessarily new, but we used to do that the first month of 2L fall. Meanwhile these students have to do it with their very first law school exams coming as early as three weeks from now.
According to one T14 tipster, the decision to jump right to callbacks beginning as early as this month caught students completely unaware. In fact, students started receiving links to sign up for callbacks within a week of sending in their applications.
Which sort of does violence to the word “callback.”
Biglaw recruiting has morphed into the doomsday machine from Dr. Strangelove. Everyone agrees it’s insane. Bloomberg Law literally titled a podcast episode “Everyone Hates Early Law School Recruiting, But Everyone Does It.” Morgan Lewis chair Jami McKeon told the outlet the firm is “absolutely” recruiting students before their first exams: “That’s what the market is right now, so you have to do it.”
There’s a lot about this that mirrors Kubrick’s classic film. Madness hiding behind suits and desks, a breakdown in norms driven by paranoia and poor communication, fascists in new jobs.
But not unlike the Cold War itself, there’s no off-ramp to runaway stockpiling. Firms started recruiting spring 1Ls, so other firms started talking to fall 1Ls. Firms started entertaining new students, handed out walking around money to other students to wine and dine classmates. Now it’s not enough to have initial interviews in the fall, we’ve got to skip right to callbacks
Since this crazy cycle got going, firms have officially made their offers contingent on the first batch of grades. But now the firms are actively scheduling callbacks during the reading period and finals. So if you spend too much time studying, you won’t even get the offer, but if you overload on interviews, you might not get the grades.
All the time that should be spent outlining Civ Pro is getting eaten up rehearsing “my greatest weakness is that I care too much” in front of a mirror.
Last cycle, Latham’s timeline promised that “interviews will accommodate your academic commitments.” Firms seem to have decided that was a sign of weakness and jumped.
Law schools have bent over to adapt to the craziness, moving jobs programming up as early as the first week of school. Harvard rewrote its guidelines to allow offers in November. But no matter how many concessions they extend the recruiting Moloch, the schools fundamentally lack leverage. Duke published an official policy that “Employers should refrain from interviewing students or hosting 1L events during the reading and exam period,” an edict that could hardly read weaker.
Not every firm is locked into this cycle of abuse. Cooley found an off switch, shrinking its 1L-cycle hiring by 30 to 40 percent, and opening up more gaps to fill after 1L year. Susman Godfrey rejected the 1L hiring model entirely. Every firm is individually rational and collectively deranged, but any firm willing to step back might lose a superstar here or there, but they’ll make it up in good will. And, let’s be serious, how many superstars can one reliably identify before they’ve even taken an exam!
Dr. Strangelove ends in mushroom clouds. No one knows where Biglaw’s version ends up. The good news is that interviewing during exams should be a thing of the past soon. Next year, they’ll start interviewing the summer before orientation.
Earlier: Top Biglaw Firm Pumps The Brakes On Early Recruiting In A Rare Win For Law Students
Exclusive: Susman Godfrey Rejects Biglaw’s Broken Recruiting Model — And Isn’t Looking Back
When Biglaw Ruins Everything, Law Schools Have To Adapt
Conservative Judges Hiring Clerks Before 1L Exams Because Ideology Is The Only Grade That Matters
OCI Is Broken—And Big Law Is Losing Its Grip
Joe Patrice is a senior editor at Above the Law and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. Feel free to email any tips, questions, or comments. Follow him on Twitter or Bluesky if you’re interested in law, politics, and a healthy dose of college sports news.
The post Biglaw Skipping 1L Interviews And Going Straight To Callbacks Before First-Semester Exams appeared first on Above the Law.

Law firms started throwing the hiring cycle into disarray a few years ago, blowing off the tried and true on-campus interviewing regime to start recruiting in the middle of the academic year. As students and law schools complained about the incursion, the firms upped the ante, beginning to interview future lawyers before students even take first-semester exams.
Now we’re hearing that at least a couple firms have gone further, eschewing initial interviews altogether and jumping straight to callbacks based on nothing but an application and vibes. Meanwhile, students have to show up to class in suits so they can bolt the moment the lecture ends. Which isn’t necessarily new, but we used to do that the first month of 2L fall. Meanwhile these students have to do it with their very first law school exams coming as early as three weeks from now.
According to one T14 tipster, the decision to jump right to callbacks beginning as early as this month caught students completely unaware. In fact, students started receiving links to sign up for callbacks within a week of sending in their applications.
Which sort of does violence to the word “callback.”
Biglaw recruiting has morphed into the doomsday machine from Dr. Strangelove. Everyone agrees it’s insane. Bloomberg Law literally titled a podcast episode “Everyone Hates Early Law School Recruiting, But Everyone Does It.” Morgan Lewis chair Jami McKeon told the outlet the firm is “absolutely” recruiting students before their first exams: “That’s what the market is right now, so you have to do it.”
There’s a lot about this that mirrors Kubrick’s classic film. Madness hiding behind suits and desks, a breakdown in norms driven by paranoia and poor communication, fascists in new jobs.
But not unlike the Cold War itself, there’s no off-ramp to runaway stockpiling. Firms started recruiting spring 1Ls, so other firms started talking to fall 1Ls. Firms started entertaining new students, handed out walking around money to other students to wine and dine classmates. Now it’s not enough to have initial interviews in the fall, we’ve got to skip right to callbacks
Since this crazy cycle got going, firms have officially made their offers contingent on the first batch of grades. But now the firms are actively scheduling callbacks during the reading period and finals. So if you spend too much time studying, you won’t even get the offer, but if you overload on interviews, you might not get the grades.
All the time that should be spent outlining Civ Pro is getting eaten up rehearsing “my greatest weakness is that I care too much” in front of a mirror.
Last cycle, Latham’s timeline promised that “interviews will accommodate your academic commitments.” Firms seem to have decided that was a sign of weakness and jumped.
Law schools have bent over to adapt to the craziness, moving jobs programming up as early as the first week of school. Harvard rewrote its guidelines to allow offers in November. But no matter how many concessions they extend the recruiting Moloch, the schools fundamentally lack leverage. Duke published an official policy that “Employers should refrain from interviewing students or hosting 1L events during the reading and exam period,” an edict that could hardly read weaker.
Not every firm is locked into this cycle of abuse. Cooley found an off switch, shrinking its 1L-cycle hiring by 30 to 40 percent, and opening up more gaps to fill after 1L year. Susman Godfrey rejected the 1L hiring model entirely. Every firm is individually rational and collectively deranged, but any firm willing to step back might lose a superstar here or there, but they’ll make it up in good will. And, let’s be serious, how many superstars can one reliably identify before they’ve even taken an exam!
Dr. Strangelove ends in mushroom clouds. No one knows where Biglaw’s version ends up. The good news is that interviewing during exams should be a thing of the past soon. Next year, they’ll start interviewing the summer before orientation.
Earlier: Top Biglaw Firm Pumps The Brakes On Early Recruiting In A Rare Win For Law Students
Exclusive: Susman Godfrey Rejects Biglaw’s Broken Recruiting Model — And Isn’t Looking Back
When Biglaw Ruins Everything, Law Schools Have To Adapt
Conservative Judges Hiring Clerks Before 1L Exams Because Ideology Is The Only Grade That Matters
OCI Is Broken—And Big Law Is Losing Its Grip
Joe Patrice is a senior editor at Above the Law and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. Feel free to email any tips, questions, or comments. Follow him on Twitter or Bluesky if you’re interested in law, politics, and a healthy dose of college sports news.

