
I recently had the good fortune to interview David Pogue. Pogue is an Emmy-winning “CBS News Sunday Morning” correspondent, best-selling author, five-time TED speaker, and host of 20 “NOVA” science specials on PBS. He also served as The New York Times’ weekly technology columnist for 13 years. I wasn’t in Kansas anymore.
Pogue will speak on November 17 at Cleveland State University College of Law’s P. Kelly Tompkins Leadership and Law Center. His talk is entitled “AI: The Coping Crash Course” and is part of the Richard W. Pogue Leadership Conversation Series. And yes, there is a family connection. The lecture series is named for Richard W. Pogue, David’s father, a former managing partner of Jones Day. So, David isn’t exactly a stranger to legal.
He plans to discuss the current state of AI in general. And, according to the press release, what happens to evidence when realistic documents, photographs, and videos can be generated with a click.
We were joined in the interview session by Brian Ray. Ray is CSU Law’s co-interim dean, Baker Hostetler chair in law, and director of the Center for Cybersecurity and Privacy Protection. Ray knows a thing or two about AI himself.
Our discussion was informal, wide-ranging, and enlightening on a number of topics. It covered everything from deepfakes and AI slop to legal education, critical thinking, and the future of work. And the most important point was that AI is going to change a lot of things. But at the end of the day, we will cope.
Deepfakes: What AI Gives, It May Take Away
Since the press release for his CSU talk mentions AI-manufactured evidence, I raised the specter of deepfakes in the courtroom and beyond. Pogue readily acknowledged that the problem is enormous and could take many forms, such as audio recordings, photographs, or even written documents.
But on the bright side, he pointed to efforts being undertaken by Adobe, Microsoft, and even Apple to create content credentials. These credentials would serve as a digital trail that, he says, will all be stored on the blockchain. Each time a photo or document is changed, these credentials would be stamped invisibly with the time, place, and person who created it.
Eventually, Pogue says, you could run a mouse over an image to see any change made to it, whether in Photoshop or simply by cropping it to post on Instagram. It would open up a side panel showing the entire life history of the picture.
If that technology is developed, it would better enable anyone in the courtroom to question any particular document. And help judges make better authentication decisions. And if no provenance shows up? That alone, says Pogue, would make it suspect.
It’s an interesting concept. AI has enabled deepfakes to be easily and realistically created. But it may also hold the key to combating the problem it created. I hope he’s right.
But I’ve sat through panels of other experts who have their doubts. They wondered how effective provenance would prove in combating the problem and the questions it raises. Indeed, the absence of a digital history doesn’t necessarily mean something is fake.
Regardless, Pogue agreed with me that “there’s also just a lot of education that needs to go on.”
The Laggard Regulation
That led into a discussion about regulation and legislation. Or the lack of it. Pogue noted that right now there’s almost no federal legislation about deepfakes or, more generally, AI. While a few states have some limited guardrails in place, that’s about it. Unfortunately, he also thinks it may take some bad events to make it happen. Pogue says that “those things will change, and all it’s going to take is another couple of really serious disasters.”
And legislators and regulators, he says, are some two years behind the technology. (If you ask me, two years is generous.) But that always happens with technology, says Pogue.
It’s a hell of a way to govern. But it is the way we do things.
AI Slop: Love Or Leave It?
I asked about AI slop. You know, the stuff produced by some lazy SOB who figured out how to generate content without doing any thinking. I wondered whether, with AI slop everywhere, we’ll all have to dumb down how we write and persuade just to reach readers who are drowning in it. Pogue pushed back pretty hard. As he put it, “Young people are getting better and better at sniffing slop a mile away, and they hate it.”
He told me a story about his book on the first 50 years of Apple. It’s a good book, by the way, especially for those people like me who are Apple enthusiasts. Pogue mentioned that he placed an AI-generated photograph of Steve Jobs in a Willy Wonka outfit in the book. He was trying to make a humorous point about one of Jobs’s outlandish ideas that didn’t work out so well. The reaction, he said, was ferocious. People hated it.
Another example he gave: the reaction most people had to the first AI-written movie. Again, the reaction was so negative that they had to cancel the show. His conclusion: “Human-generated stuff is valued much more than AI stuff. That will be the case for some time.”
Ray added an interesting point. He thinks much of the AI marketing slop is written not because a human is going to read it, but for search engine optimization (SEO). That could explain why we are seeing so much of this crap.
But neither believed that AI slop is going to replace good human writing. At least not anytime soon.
Erosion Of Critical Thinking: It’s All Because You Can Work In Your PJs
I raised the question with Pogue and Ray about the potential erosion of critical thinking in young lawyers. The concern is that many of the tasks they were assigned in their early years as associates will now be done by AI. How will young lawyers be trained? It’s a bedeviling question.
Their take was interesting. Pogue thinks the erosion may have more to do with remote work than with AI. He observed that people have always learned a field through friction. They learned by working side by side and watching experienced people make decisions. Remote work took much of that away. That’s why, he and Ray agreed, the pendulum is swinging back toward return to the office. Hard.
I’m not sure I agree with this. I spent enough years in law firms to know that putting lawyers in the same building doesn’t necessarily mean they’re learning from one another. I’ve seen plenty of associates and partners come into the office, close their doors, and spend the entire day working alone. Being physically present doesn’t automatically create training.
But Pogue’s point is an interesting take. It’s critical we keep an open mind about both cause and effect in the age of AI.
The Future Doesn’t Give A Damn About Your Fears
We talked a bit about the future with AI and where everything is going. Pogue’s take on where we were headed with AI might have been the most important: “You’re being tempted to be depressed by all of this, as many, many people are. I would just say that we are so new to this realm that nobody can see the future, not the optimist, and not the pessimist. No one can see around the corner.”
He told me that part of his talk will demonstrate that things like this have happened before and humanity survived. For example, with the invention of radio, the internet, and even elevators, the pundits all proclaimed it would be the end of mankind. Or at least something close.
As Pogue put it, “We fear new technologies because we haven’t sorted it all out and we don’t have social guardrails or legal guardrails. We don’t know what to expect, so we expect the worst.” He noted even Socrates bemoaned the invention of written language because he thought no one would have to remember anything. So, the doom and gloom is not new.
Ray’s take was a bit more nuanced. He believes that AI disruption will be on the scale of the Industrial Revolution. He thinks there is indeed going to be a lot of pain and upheaval in the short term as the economics of work and how work gets distributed play out. He stressed that the ability to think like a lawyer and to work through problems methodically and logically, along with identifying valid sources, is going to be more valuable than ever.
Because of this, he says that law schools need to keep iterating on how they teach and give their students proper access to AI tools. But, says Ray, “I suspect law, medicine, and certain other areas are going to be places where, no matter what, we want humans.”
The Curious Cases Of Software Engineers And Radiologists
Pogue is also bullish on the future of lawyers, though he agrees that there will be significant economic change, which we can’t yet clearly predict. In that regard, he did note that something “really weird” is going on with at least two professions that may be instructive.
There were predictions two years ago that software engineers would disappear. The reason: AI writes code much faster, better, and cheaper than any human. Instead, Pogue says there is more demand for software engineers today than there was two years ago. Why? Humans are still needed to review all the code that’s being created.
Similarly, he also told me that there was a belief that radiologists would disappear. AI can review radiological scans much faster and better than a human, so who needs them? However, he says that also hasn’t happened. There is more demand for radiologists today than ever, and it’s because, he says, “they’ve turned their time to all the other stuff that matters more. Talking to patients, studying results, prescribing outcomes, and the like.”
While AI will disrupt, we don’t yet know the outcomes.
Stay Hungry. Stay Foolish.
Talking to Pogue and Ray was refreshing. Their optimism for the future was palpable. They clearly believe that AI will dominate our future in ways that we cannot yet predict. But we will adapt. And I think Pogue’s examples of past disruptions are instructive. However, I also have to add that I don’t know that we’ve ever seen a disruptive power as comprehensive as AI.
But as I’ve said before, lawyers, and for that matter, humans, are a resilient lot. We’ve survived substantial disruption and upheavals before. I’m reminded of the famous William Gibson quote: “The future is already here. It’s just not evenly distributed.” There will be winners and losers, economically and otherwise, as AI continues to progress.
AI will change a lot of things. We don’t yet know the what or the how. But if Pogue and Ray are right, the crash course is less about predicting the future than about coping with it. Like the closing line from The Last Whole Earth Catalog back in my day: Stay hungry. Stay foolish.
We got this.
Stephen Embry is a lawyer, speaker, blogger, and writer. He publishes TechLaw Crossroads, a blog devoted to the examination of the tension between technology, the law, and the practice of law.
The post An Interview With David Pogue: AI Will Change A Lot. We’ll Cope. appeared first on Above the Law.

I recently had the good fortune to interview David Pogue. Pogue is an Emmy-winning “CBS News Sunday Morning” correspondent, best-selling author, five-time TED speaker, and host of 20 “NOVA” science specials on PBS. He also served as The New York Times’ weekly technology columnist for 13 years. I wasn’t in Kansas anymore.
Pogue will speak on November 17 at Cleveland State University College of Law’s P. Kelly Tompkins Leadership and Law Center. His talk is entitled “AI: The Coping Crash Course” and is part of the Richard W. Pogue Leadership Conversation Series. And yes, there is a family connection. The lecture series is named for Richard W. Pogue, David’s father, a former managing partner of Jones Day. So, David isn’t exactly a stranger to legal.
He plans to discuss the current state of AI in general. And, according to the press release, what happens to evidence when realistic documents, photographs, and videos can be generated with a click.
We were joined in the interview session by Brian Ray. Ray is CSU Law’s co-interim dean, Baker Hostetler chair in law, and director of the Center for Cybersecurity and Privacy Protection. Ray knows a thing or two about AI himself.
Our discussion was informal, wide-ranging, and enlightening on a number of topics. It covered everything from deepfakes and AI slop to legal education, critical thinking, and the future of work. And the most important point was that AI is going to change a lot of things. But at the end of the day, we will cope.
Deepfakes: What AI Gives, It May Take Away
Since the press release for his CSU talk mentions AI-manufactured evidence, I raised the specter of deepfakes in the courtroom and beyond. Pogue readily acknowledged that the problem is enormous and could take many forms, such as audio recordings, photographs, or even written documents.
But on the bright side, he pointed to efforts being undertaken by Adobe, Microsoft, and even Apple to create content credentials. These credentials would serve as a digital trail that, he says, will all be stored on the blockchain. Each time a photo or document is changed, these credentials would be stamped invisibly with the time, place, and person who created it.
Eventually, Pogue says, you could run a mouse over an image to see any change made to it, whether in Photoshop or simply by cropping it to post on Instagram. It would open up a side panel showing the entire life history of the picture.
If that technology is developed, it would better enable anyone in the courtroom to question any particular document. And help judges make better authentication decisions. And if no provenance shows up? That alone, says Pogue, would make it suspect.
It’s an interesting concept. AI has enabled deepfakes to be easily and realistically created. But it may also hold the key to combating the problem it created. I hope he’s right.
But I’ve sat through panels of other experts who have their doubts. They wondered how effective provenance would prove in combating the problem and the questions it raises. Indeed, the absence of a digital history doesn’t necessarily mean something is fake.
Regardless, Pogue agreed with me that “there’s also just a lot of education that needs to go on.”
The Laggard Regulation
That led into a discussion about regulation and legislation. Or the lack of it. Pogue noted that right now there’s almost no federal legislation about deepfakes or, more generally, AI. While a few states have some limited guardrails in place, that’s about it. Unfortunately, he also thinks it may take some bad events to make it happen. Pogue says that “those things will change, and all it’s going to take is another couple of really serious disasters.”
And legislators and regulators, he says, are some two years behind the technology. (If you ask me, two years is generous.) But that always happens with technology, says Pogue.
It’s a hell of a way to govern. But it is the way we do things.
AI Slop: Love Or Leave It?
I asked about AI slop. You know, the stuff produced by some lazy SOB who figured out how to generate content without doing any thinking. I wondered whether, with AI slop everywhere, we’ll all have to dumb down how we write and persuade just to reach readers who are drowning in it. Pogue pushed back pretty hard. As he put it, “Young people are getting better and better at sniffing slop a mile away, and they hate it.”
He told me a story about his book on the first 50 years of Apple. It’s a good book, by the way, especially for those people like me who are Apple enthusiasts. Pogue mentioned that he placed an AI-generated photograph of Steve Jobs in a Willy Wonka outfit in the book. He was trying to make a humorous point about one of Jobs’s outlandish ideas that didn’t work out so well. The reaction, he said, was ferocious. People hated it.
Another example he gave: the reaction most people had to the first AI-written movie. Again, the reaction was so negative that they had to cancel the show. His conclusion: “Human-generated stuff is valued much more than AI stuff. That will be the case for some time.”
Ray added an interesting point. He thinks much of the AI marketing slop is written not because a human is going to read it, but for search engine optimization (SEO). That could explain why we are seeing so much of this crap.
But neither believed that AI slop is going to replace good human writing. At least not anytime soon.
Erosion Of Critical Thinking: It’s All Because You Can Work In Your PJs
I raised the question with Pogue and Ray about the potential erosion of critical thinking in young lawyers. The concern is that many of the tasks they were assigned in their early years as associates will now be done by AI. How will young lawyers be trained? It’s a bedeviling question.
Their take was interesting. Pogue thinks the erosion may have more to do with remote work than with AI. He observed that people have always learned a field through friction. They learned by working side by side and watching experienced people make decisions. Remote work took much of that away. That’s why, he and Ray agreed, the pendulum is swinging back toward return to the office. Hard.
I’m not sure I agree with this. I spent enough years in law firms to know that putting lawyers in the same building doesn’t necessarily mean they’re learning from one another. I’ve seen plenty of associates and partners come into the office, close their doors, and spend the entire day working alone. Being physically present doesn’t automatically create training.
But Pogue’s point is an interesting take. It’s critical we keep an open mind about both cause and effect in the age of AI.
The Future Doesn’t Give A Damn About Your Fears
We talked a bit about the future with AI and where everything is going. Pogue’s take on where we were headed with AI might have been the most important: “You’re being tempted to be depressed by all of this, as many, many people are. I would just say that we are so new to this realm that nobody can see the future, not the optimist, and not the pessimist. No one can see around the corner.”
He told me that part of his talk will demonstrate that things like this have happened before and humanity survived. For example, with the invention of radio, the internet, and even elevators, the pundits all proclaimed it would be the end of mankind. Or at least something close.
As Pogue put it, “We fear new technologies because we haven’t sorted it all out and we don’t have social guardrails or legal guardrails. We don’t know what to expect, so we expect the worst.” He noted even Socrates bemoaned the invention of written language because he thought no one would have to remember anything. So, the doom and gloom is not new.
Ray’s take was a bit more nuanced. He believes that AI disruption will be on the scale of the Industrial Revolution. He thinks there is indeed going to be a lot of pain and upheaval in the short term as the economics of work and how work gets distributed play out. He stressed that the ability to think like a lawyer and to work through problems methodically and logically, along with identifying valid sources, is going to be more valuable than ever.
Because of this, he says that law schools need to keep iterating on how they teach and give their students proper access to AI tools. But, says Ray, “I suspect law, medicine, and certain other areas are going to be places where, no matter what, we want humans.”
The Curious Cases Of Software Engineers And Radiologists
Pogue is also bullish on the future of lawyers, though he agrees that there will be significant economic change, which we can’t yet clearly predict. In that regard, he did note that something “really weird” is going on with at least two professions that may be instructive.
There were predictions two years ago that software engineers would disappear. The reason: AI writes code much faster, better, and cheaper than any human. Instead, Pogue says there is more demand for software engineers today than there was two years ago. Why? Humans are still needed to review all the code that’s being created.
Similarly, he also told me that there was a belief that radiologists would disappear. AI can review radiological scans much faster and better than a human, so who needs them? However, he says that also hasn’t happened. There is more demand for radiologists today than ever, and it’s because, he says, “they’ve turned their time to all the other stuff that matters more. Talking to patients, studying results, prescribing outcomes, and the like.”
While AI will disrupt, we don’t yet know the outcomes.
Stay Hungry. Stay Foolish.
Talking to Pogue and Ray was refreshing. Their optimism for the future was palpable. They clearly believe that AI will dominate our future in ways that we cannot yet predict. But we will adapt. And I think Pogue’s examples of past disruptions are instructive. However, I also have to add that I don’t know that we’ve ever seen a disruptive power as comprehensive as AI.
But as I’ve said before, lawyers, and for that matter, humans, are a resilient lot. We’ve survived substantial disruption and upheavals before. I’m reminded of the famous William Gibson quote: “The future is already here. It’s just not evenly distributed.” There will be winners and losers, economically and otherwise, as AI continues to progress.
AI will change a lot of things. We don’t yet know the what or the how. But if Pogue and Ray are right, the crash course is less about predicting the future than about coping with it. Like the closing line from The Last Whole Earth Catalog back in my day: Stay hungry. Stay foolish.
We got this.
Stephen Embry is a lawyer, speaker, blogger, and writer. He publishes TechLaw Crossroads, a blog devoted to the examination of the tension between technology, the law, and the practice of law.
The post An Interview With David Pogue: AI Will Change A Lot. We’ll Cope. appeared first on Above the Law.

