Select Page

Every child ordered to apologize for smacking their sibling has pulled the “you can’t make me” retort. And they’re technically correct. But they soon learn that parents can absolutely take away their toys when they don’t hear an apology.

Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill is on the cusp of learning the same lesson.

Back in September, the SEC sued LSU in federal court in Alabama because Lane Kiffin tried to sign former NFL players to play for the team with the blessing of a friendly state judge. LSU backed down, but the case kept going anyway — because now LSU wants to add a former basketball professional — and in an October 20 reply brief, Murrill told the court that “key SEC citations … appear to be negligently supplied or hallucinated.”

On Wednesday, U.S. District Judge Annemarie Carney Axon had some thoughts about that accusation given that the cases were absolutely real. LSU’s local counsel, Bruce Rogers, conceded the cases were real — “They’re not made-up cases” — and argued “hallucinated” was a broader term for LSU just not agreeing with the citations.

This strategy worked… poorly.

Axon asked Rogers, “Do you consider attacks on people’s professional reputation and character to be legitimate advocacy?”

Rogers said no.

“You wouldn’t want somebody to wrongly accuse you of hallucinating a case, knowing full well what the implication of that accusation is,” Axon said.

Rogers again said there was a broader definition to the term “hallucinated.”

“We’re not dressing this up, OK?” Axon said. “You put the pig out there. There’s no time for you to put lipstick on it.”

Judge Axon ordered Rogers to move to strike the word and admit that it reflected “poor professional judgment.” She also directed Rogers, LSU, and the AG’s office to send her “robust, heartfelt” press releases expressing regret, and warned that “if this happens one more time, you are going to be sanctioned to the fullest extent I can.”

Rather than accept the scolding and save face, Murrill announced that she “cannot and will not apologize for my lawyers doing their job,” and that it’s “improper for an Alabama federal judge to compel speech from the State of Louisiana” as if federal practice is some sort of interstate rivalry. Louisiana governor Jeff Landry compounded this misreading of the stakes, posting on social media to attack “The University of Alabama alumni judge.” Guys, this is not helping.

Murrill then submitted a letter to the court asserting that since the SEC acknowledges using AI as part of its workflow, it’s “well within the bounds of zealous representation” to claim that any cite Louisiana doesn’t like amounts to a hallucination.

Notably, this is NOT the tack local counsel took in the hearing. While also unsuccessful, that lawyer at least tried to spin “hallucination” as though it wasn’t an AI charge. Murrill, who has seemed in over her head at every stage of this case except when performing for state judges within steps of campus, decided to adopt the “sure we knew ‘hallucination’ is a serious professional accusation, we just think it’s fair game to sling that mud as long as the other side admits to having access to Harvey.”

Judge Axon already brought up the glow-up pig, but this is more like that infamous LBJ story where aides told the young future president to stop baselessly accusing a rival candidate of having sex with his hogs and Johnson refused, saying “let’s make the sonofabitch deny it.” You can’t go around claiming the other side hallucinated cases — that you could easily look up and prove are real — just to make them defend themselves.

There’s a legal nerd battle over whether mixed conjunctive and disjunctive phrasings can legitimately be grouped under the same “See” signal, and Louisiana is parachuting naked into the tailgate holding a Busch Light and an American flag proclaiming it don’t matter if the cases are real, we can call them hallucinations anyway! Is this fictionalized avatar for misplaced bravado claiming they can do this because of ‘Murica? You’d better believe it:

Second, as our briefing on compelled speech explains, ECF 32 at 8, Defendants—appointed and elected officials of a sovereign state sued in their official capacities—have a free speech right that flows from our constitutional structure. That right includes both the right to speak and the right not to speak. Wooley v. Maynard, 430 U.S. 705, 714 (1977). In this regard, “[t]he compelled speech doctrine” prohibits government compulsion of speech—unless the government can satisfy strict scrutiny. E.g., McClendon v. Long, 22 F.4th 1330, 1337-38 (11th Cir. 2022). Respectfully, the Court’s directive that the State of Louisiana publish a particular message and submit to the Court’s editing of that message violates basic free speech principles and does not satisfy strict scrutiny. As a result, my office cannot comply with this directive.

To quote The Big Lebowski, “this is not a First Amendment thing, man.” It’s true that the Court can’t compel speech, but the judge isn’t so much “compelling speech,” as inviting Louisiana to cure its breach before getting benchslapped into oblivion. This is the crossroads where the child decides if having access to their Switch for the next month merits eating a little crow.

Either the state has chosen to accept its licks or has no idea that the “apology” is more an off-ramp than an order.

Also, reflect upon the hypocrisy of Liz Murrill draping herself in the First Amendment. This is the same AG that spent time and tons of taxpayer money defending LSU for suspending a law professor for criticizing Donald Trump.

One voice that seems to get this is Tom Mars:

Mars continues to be the Cassandra of this case. He’s the same Kiffin confidant who spent September begging the coach to stop taking legal advice from ChatGPT. Now he’s counseling the AG to understand how sanctions work and warning the governor to stop making things worse. Someone who cares about Louisiana needs to put Mars in charge of all this.

For a case born out of ChatGPT legal advice, it takes some gumption to cast aspersions on Harvey.

At least Murrill did approve striking the “hallucination” language from the original filing. That might be sufficient to avoid sanction. But stirring that move in with telling the judge that the court “lacks jurisdiction” and grandstanding about free speech isn’t winning Louisiana much grace here.

It’s one thing for the state to toss decorum to the wind in state court, but this is a road game and Murrill is performing about as well as the Tigers have on the road this season. Remember, Louisiana is fighting this fight in defense of a team that’s gone 6-4 despite being favored in every game this year. Taking a bold, defiant stand on shaky ground only to expensively fail anyway is an apt encapsulation of both the team and the litigation.

And this could prove quite expensive. Yesterday, Georgia Attorney General Chris Carr sent SEC Commissioner Greg Sankey a letter focused on LSU securing another friendly state court order to sign a former professional basketball player, but that cannot be divorced from the context of Murrill publicly defying the federal court:

… the SEC must take appropriate action to sanction LSU, up to and including expulsion, in accordance with the established rules of the Conference.

Carr’s letter says of the basketball signing that, “No one is forcing LSU to do this,” which applies just as well to Judge Axon’s apology request.

Earlier: Lane Kiffin Is EXACTLY The Guy Who Uses ChatGPT For Legal Advice
No, Supreme Court Gun Case Isn’t Based On A ‘Misquote.’ What Scalia Did Was Way More Intellectually Dishonest


HeadshotJoe Patrice is a senior editor at Above the Law and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. Feel free to email any tips, questions, or comments. Follow him on Twitter or Bluesky if you’re interested in law, politics, and a healthy dose of college sports news.

The post Attacking Judge Over Free Speech Only To Run Face First Into Sanctions Is Perfect Metaphor For LSU Football appeared first on Above the Law.

Benchslapped 01

Every child ordered to apologize for smacking their sibling has pulled the “you can’t make me” retort. And they’re technically correct. But they soon learn that parents can absolutely take away their toys when they don’t hear an apology.

Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill is on the cusp of learning the same lesson.

Back in September, the SEC sued LSU in federal court in Alabama because Lane Kiffin tried to sign former NFL players to play for the team with the blessing of a friendly state judge. LSU backed down, but the case kept going anyway — because now LSU wants to add a former basketball professional — and in an October 20 reply brief, Murrill told the court that “key SEC citations … appear to be negligently supplied or hallucinated.”

On Wednesday, U.S. District Judge Annemarie Carney Axon had some thoughts about that accusation given that the cases were absolutely real. LSU’s local counsel, Bruce Rogers, conceded the cases were real — “They’re not made-up cases” — and argued “hallucinated” was a broader term for LSU just not agreeing that the citations.

This strategy worked… poorly.

Axon asked Rogers, “Do you consider attacks on people’s professional reputation and character to be legitimate advocacy?”

Rogers said no.

“You wouldn’t want somebody to wrongly accuse you of hallucinating a case, knowing full well what the implication of that accusation is,” Axon said.

Rogers again said there was a broader definition to the term “hallucinated.”

“We’re not dressing this up, OK?” Axon said. “You put the pig out there. There’s no time for you to put lipstick on it.”

Judge Axon ordered Rogers to move to strike the word and admit that it reflected “poor professional judgment.” She also directed Rogers, LSU, and the AG’s office to send her “robust, heartfelt” press releases expressing regret, and warned that “if this happens one more time, you are going to be sanctioned to the fullest extent I can.”

Rather than accept the scolding and save face, Murrill announced that she “cannot and will not apologize for my lawyers doing their job,” and that it’s “improper for an Alabama federal judge to compel speech from the State of Louisiana” as if federal practice is some sort of interstate rivalry. Louisiana governor Jeff Landry compounded this misreading of the stakes, posting on social media to attack “The University of Alabama alumni judge.” Guys, this is not helping.

Murrill then submitted a letter to the court asserting that since the SEC acknowledges using AI as part of its workflow, it’s “well within the bounds of zealous representation” to claim that any cite Louisiana doesn’t like amounts to a hallucination.

Notably, this is NOT the tack local counsel took in the hearing. While also unsuccessful, that lawyer at least tried to spin “hallucination” as though it wasn’t an AI charge. Murrill, who has seemed in over her head at every stage of this case except when performing for state judges within steps of campus, decided to adopt the “sure we knew ‘hallucination’ is a serious professional accusation, we just think it’s fair game to sling that mud as long as the other side admits to having access to Harvey.”

Judge Axon already brought up the glow-up pig, but this is more like that infamous LBJ story where aides told the young future president to stop baselessly accusing a rival candidate of having sex with his hogs and Johnson refused, saying “let’s make the sonofabitch deny it.” You can’t go around claiming the other side hallucinated cases — that you could easily look up and prove are real — just to make them defend themselves.

There’s a legal nerd battle over whether mixed conjunctive and disjunctive phrasings can legitimately be grouped under the same “See” signal, and Louisiana is parachuting naked into the tailgate holding a Busch Light and an American flag proclaiming it don’t matter if the cases are real, we can call them hallucinations anyway! Is this fictionalized avatar for misplaced bravado claiming they can do this because of ‘Murica? You’d better believe it:

Second, as our briefing on compelled speech explains, ECF 32 at 8, Defendants—appointed and elected officials of a sovereign state sued in their official capacities—have a free speech right that flows from our constitutional structure. That right includes both the right to speak and the right not to speak. Wooley v. Maynard, 430 U.S. 705, 714 (1977). In this regard, “[t]he compelled speech doctrine” prohibits government compulsion of speech—unless the government can satisfy strict scrutiny. E.g., McClendon v. Long, 22 F.4th 1330, 1337-38 (11th Cir. 2022). Respectfully, the Court’s directive that the State of Louisiana publish a particular message and submit to the Court’s editing of that message violates basic free speech principles and does not satisfy strict scrutiny. As a result, my office cannot comply with this directive.

To quote The Big Lebowski, “this is not a First Amendment thing, man.” It’s true that the Court can’t compel speech, but the judge isn’t so much “compelling speech,” as inviting Louisiana to cure its breach before getting benchslapped into oblivion. This is the crossroads where the child decides if having access to their Switch for the next month merits eating a little crow.

Either the state has chosen to accept its licks or has no idea that the “apology” is more an off-ramp than an order.

Also, reflect upon the hypocrisy of Liz Murrill draping herself in the First Amendment. This is the same AG that spent time and tons of taxpayer money defending LSU for suspending a law professor for criticizing Donald Trump.

One voice that seems to get this is Tom Mars:

Louisiana AG and LSU: You may be a federal judge, but you don’t have the authority to compel us to make an apology.

Federal Judge: You’re right, of course. You win. I figured you would prefer that approach instead of having me choose from the long list of sanctions I do have… https://t.co/Jrzdq8fCXR

— Tom Mars (@TomMarsLaw)

November 19, 2026

Mars continues to be the Cassandra of this case. He’s the same Kiffin confidant who spent September begging the coach to stop taking legal advice from ChatGPT. Now he’s counseling the AG to understand how sanctions work and warning the governor to stop making things worse. Someone who cares about Louisiana needs to put Mars in charge of all this.

For a case born out of ChatGPT legal advice, it takes some gumption to cast aspersions on Harvey.

At least Murrill did approve striking the “hallucination” language from the original filing. That might be sufficient to avoid sanction. But stirring that move in with telling the judge that the court “lacks jurisdiction” and grandstanding about free speech isn’t winning Louisiana much grace here.

It’s one thing for the state to toss decorum to the wind in state court, but this is a road game and Murrill is performing about as well as the Tigers have on the road this season. Remember, Louisiana is fighting this fight in defense of a team that’s gone 6-4 despite being favored in every game this year. Taking a bold, defiant stand on shaky ground only to expensively fail anyway is an apt encapsulation of both the team and the litigation.

And this could prove quite expensive. Yesterday, Georgia Attorney General Chris Carr sent SEC Commissioner Greg Sankey a letter focused on LSU securing another friendly state court order to sign a former professional basketball player, but that cannot be divorced from the context of Murrill publicly defying the federal court:

… the SEC must take appropriate action to sanction LSU, up to and including expulsion, in accordance with the established rules of the Conference.

Carr’s letter says of the basketball signing that, “No one is forcing LSU to do this,” which applies just as well to Judge Axon’s apology request.

Earlier: Lane Kiffin Is EXACTLY The Guy Who Uses ChatGPT For Legal Advice
No, Supreme Court Gun Case Isn’t Based On A ‘Misquote.’ What Scalia Did Was Way More Intellectually Dishonest


HeadshotJoe Patrice is a senior editor at Above the Law and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. Feel free to email any tips, questions, or comments. Follow him on Twitter or Bluesky if you’re interested in law, politics, and a healthy dose of college sports news.